Much like its namesake, this polish ate and left no crumbs. Created in collaboration with Safiya Nygaard, this sharky teal linear holographic easily swam its way into our hearts and shopping carts. We wish Brucie a stress-free retirement party at the bottom of a sparkling ocean.

It’s never easy to lay an icon to rest. This berry shade of crushed holo was designed in collaboration with Safiya Nygaard and helped bring her franken beauty experiments to manicured life. We thank all the lipsticks sacrificed that inspired this shade and wish it the most peaceful retirement on the rack.

You couldn’t handle this jelly holo. Mixed up for our 4th Anniversary Retro Collection, this purple and holo jelly polish became the envied Anti-Hero of the bunch. While we’re sad for this polish to hang up its cape, it’s time to think forward to year five.

Visions of this blue jelly and scattered holo polish will forever be playing back in our minds. Created in celebration of our 4th Anniversary, Be Kind Rewind was a Retro Collection staple blue that evoked simpler times of slumber parties and movie nights. Like a VHS, it’s now spending eternity on the shelf.

This orange jelly with scattered holo was far from a Box Office Bomb. Released as part of our 4th Anniversary Retro Collection, this stunning shade turned boring nails into orange movie stars. Please pay respects and remain seated while its credits roll.

Meet the polish that kicked standard-definition nails up a notch. Its highlighter-yellow jelly base set the stage for our 4th Anniversary Retro Collection. Although its career must be put on pause, Hi-Def will continue to be featured in our memories.